Counting Calories Frustrating You? Try Calorie Shifting
- by Joey Atlas, Author of Amazon Bestseller – ‘Fatness to Fitness’
—————————————————————————————————————
If Counting Calories is Frustrating You? You May Want to Try Calorie Shifting
I originally wrote this article for my ‘members only’ site, BestFitnessAdvice.com – and its a strategy that has helped a handful of people make some serious improvements in their health and body – primarily from body fat reduction.
Several weeks ago I sent out a free PDF success story that was submitted to me from, Lisa, one of our members. She mentioned the impact that calorie shifting had on her success when combined with the Leg, Butt, Hip and Thigh program, with changing her body and life – and we got a ton of emails asking more about the ‘calorie shifting’ concept.
—————
So here it is. Enjoy it – use it – and please share your results with us…
The challenge of eating a nutrient dense, low calorie diet that promotes healthy weight and optimal fitness – while at the same time trying to keep daily caloric intake at appropriate levels for one’s goals (usually fat/weight loss) can be one the most difficult juggling acts to master. In working with many clients with various daily habits and patterns – I’ve realized that a good number of people can benefit from “shifting their calories” instead of just counting calories to accomplish healthy nutrition and weight management.
Depending on the time you wake up in the morning – starting your day with breakfast may not be the ideal way to kick off the fulfillment of your daily nutritional needs. Now, I know this goes against traditional advice, but read on to fully understand this approach as it applies to counting calories.
I’ve worked with clients in the past who have tried to eat breakfast (in many forms and variations) first thing in the morning, and they would find that doing this made them hungrier the rest of the day and it usually led to increased daily caloric intake – enough to cause long term weight gain.
There are some people who wake up relatively early and start the day with breakfast and continue to eat relatively well throughout the day. Often, these types of people, although eating healthy foods, are taking in too many calories in the span of a whole day and either have trouble losing weight or continue to gain weight.
Now, for the caloric shifting part. We will talk about meal shifting (instead of calorie shifting) to keep matters simple – but understand, a meal is made up of calories.
A simple strategy for those who find that keeping a lid on daily caloric intake is a challenge – is to push back the time that the first meal is eaten. Lets call this meal breakfast, even though some people may find it strange to call a meal eaten at 10:30 or 11 am, breakfast.
So, instead of eating your normal breakfast at 6:30 or 8 am, you don’t skip it, you just push it back a few hours – toward your normal lunch time. In effect, you are moving, most likely, 300 – 500 (maybe more) calories and taking them in at a later time, maybe 3 or 4 hours later than normal.
Here is what happens to most people who I coach with this method. They find they are not starving for a big lunch (which also gets pushed back a few hours – to about 2pm (give or take 30 minutes). Additionally, they are not ravenous by dinner time, when most people self destruct and do so until bedtime, by snacking after dinner.
So, a result of this meal shifting is a reduction in ‘overactive appetite’ – not a bad reduction, but a healthy reduction – one that is very helpful in preventing one from over-stuffing the stomach and going beyond their daily caloric needs, day after day after day. (This is how people ’slowly’ gain a lot of weight over the span of several years.)
Lets back up a little – if dinner time food raids are a challenge, then this meal shifting can help you reduce that eating urge after work and put you in a better position to control the volume of food you put on your plate and the number of calories you put in your body.
So, ‘the calorie shift’ is also helpful for people who snack every few hours once they do start eating. By delaying when you start eating in the morning – you also delay the snack intervals you enjoy – and in effect you may reduce your total daily snacks to 2 or 3 instead of 5 or 6 (including your after dinner snack). When all is said and done, by days end you will have taken in less calories than you would have, had you started with an early breakfast.
Common ’side effects’ of this strategy are increased energy, less bloating and stomach discomfort, better sleep patterns and a few others. Hmm – I wonder why?
There are several factors inside of this calorie based fat-loss strategy to be aware of. The types of foods you choose, the volume of foods you choose and the realization that you need less calories than you think you do to function optimally on a day to day basis.
I also realize that this may go against the “You’ll shut down your metabolism, by starving yourself!” crowd. But believe me, this is far from starving yourself, very far. I tell you this firsthand, because it’s how I’ve helped many people take control of their, nutrition, body weight and fitness – and it’s how I manage my own daily nutrition and my metabolism keeps burning right along.
Now, I would like for you to help me circulate this article via social media – so I can share more of these with you in the future. See the ‘Share This’ button below? Click it and you’ll see several easy ways to help me circulate this article. Digg and StumbleUpon are 2 of the easiest, and they are free to join (actually all of them are free) – just click on the link to each and the rest is simple – takes about 90 seconds…
Comments or questions? Just post them below…
Your Trainer,
![]()
Popularity: unranked [?]
Popularity: unranked [?]
Tags: calorie counting, count calories, food calories, low calorie diet

what if i wake up at 2 pm and sleep at 4 am, i eat at 2pm – 5pm- 8pm. so what do i do in this case? knowing that i eat healthy and exercise from 7pm to 9pm ( joey’s lower body+ few upper body workouts+45mn abs). then at 11pm i walk for1hour1/2. but when i get back god i wanna eat something sweet.
what is your advice on thisjoey?
I don’t know about that…it sounds strange. I woke up late this morning, ate breakfast at about 10 am and I feel lke crap. I don’t believe this is for everyone, but it makes sense. The worst time for me is in the afternoon…once I eat a snack I can’t seem to stop snacking until dinner. =S
What about workouts in the morning. I’ve been told that i should eat something prior to my workouts. Is it ok to not eat before cardio and the Legg, Butt, Hip and Thigh Workout? There is so much confusion about when to eat in relation to workouts.
Joey
I found your website last summer and have been receiving emails from you since than, however as much as I would like to get in shape I get very discouraged because I look at myself in the mirror and think who am I kidding. I’m 62 years old, why do I care. I’m not over weight, I’m around 116lbs 5ft”1. I have gained most of my weight through my middle section, not so much my stomach but the area below my wast is one problem area. I have gained through my shoulders and arms and it just drives me nuts because my bones are small. I should be a size 2 instead of a 4 or 6. I just don’t know where to start. I use to be so faithful to excercising and keeping myself in shape but the last few years it seems I start than I loose interest because I am so busy and can’t find time to fit everything in. My 13 yr old Granddaughter lives with me so my time is not always my own. I just feel fat.
I was going to ask the same thing as Heather. I think I will still expand on it. For those that workout in the morning I have heard that A. You should eat something around an hour prior to working out and B. You should eat something (with the right carb/protein ratios which I fear I will never understand.) within 45 min of working our to repair the muscles. Do you disagree with both these theories??
I think this make sense and I know that as with everything good it is just a suggestion among many. For exercise follows the “to each their own” philosophy” just like most things in life. What works for Jane may not work for Mary. I am sure this is just what some people are looking for but not sure it would work for me. I get shaky and incredibly hungry if I wait to long to eat especially post workout (which is in the AM) and end up making all kinds of terrible food choices! I don’t just over eat I eat CRAP! But I am curious as to your answers to Heather’s and my questions.
love the article. where is my upper body workout?! Love ya Joey
I second the question of April “You should eat something (with the right carb/protein ratios which I fear I will never understand.) within 45 min of working our to repair the muscles”. I would rather not eat within the “golden hour” after I workout, but keep reading that is when you repair the muscle you worked. What are your thoughts?
I have always thought of breakfast as
BREAKING A FAST.
You fast all night. I never gained weight in my whole life until I started eating a huge breakfast.
Even a small breakfast of say 250 calories shortly after I get up seemed to keep the pounds on me. I was losing very slowly.
Oddly enough, two weeks ago, (before I read Joey’s latest article) I decided to start waiting for hours after I get up in the morning to eat! I have already lost 4.5 pounds.
I am eating extremely healthy and getting in about 1500-1600 calories a day.
I eat dinner (supper) at 7:00 PM and I have a bedtime snack at 8:00 PM. I go to bed at 9:00 and I don’t eat anything else.
I get up at 5:30 and I grab a piece of Wasa toast hours later like at 8:00 AM on my way to walk. It’s only got 70 calories in it.
I walk 4 miles every day in hilly terrain, so I take a liter of water w/me on these walks and half an apple or 3-4 prunnes for the end of the walk.
I come home at 10:00 and eat a really light snack like some nuts or something high protein. Then I do my UHBTM or if I am working upper body that day I do that.
Then I eat lunch at 1:00. This is all really working for me.
I’m eating around the clock, but there is still something about taking that 12-13 hour break of eating nothing that really has helped.
I quit smoking 3-4 years ago, and I think food become my substitute.
Good luck to everyone.
Marie
Reading your questions I wanted to respond with how I view this information and your responses. Joey is trying to say that this is another option not the only way. Basically you have to find what works best for you given all of the information. Do the work of testing it out, get in tune with your body and listen to it. If it doesn’t work try something else out until you find what works for you as we are all somewhat different. That is the way it is with all of life not just exercise and eating. He is sharing the succeses he has found to help others but not telling them it is the only way just suggestions on what helped others. Good luck to all of us on the path of life. Stay positive and be happy that we are just here living life trying to learn and better ourselves every day in every way.
How do you guys have time in your lives for 3-4 mile walks or spend hours working out? I get up at 6am most days and spend 45 minutes driving to work. I am an engineer and work about 10 hours a day and run around a factory like crazy until my lunch at noon. The problem is that I would love to calorie/meal shift but there is no way I can sneak in a meal at 10:30 in the morning. I have to wait until my lunch at noon. Is waiting to eat my first meal of the day at noon way too late?
meg
I too get up early, usually around 5 -5:30..my hunger really starts to kick in around 8 a.m., so I have some whole grain toast with a little peanut butter, drink a ton of water and then do my workout, eat a healthy lunch and eat dinner around 5 to 6ish..I don’t really snack on anything unhealthy,if I wanted to do that I would have to go buy it, don’t keep it at home. My goal is an 11 pound weight loss…and this time it will happen.
Thank you for this article,I will follow it.
hi joey its really a nice article u know i am using this regimen since like 2month and i feel good because the sensation of starving and craving for food has decreased greatly and i am trying to choose healthier types of food besides practicing exs.
yes u do have a point thanks
EveryBODY is not the same. Some try to store the calories in a first meal after a fast (8 or more hours without food) thinking that there may be another period of no calorie intake. This is usually the case for longer fasts. That results in weight gain.
Some BODIES don’t do that! The body needs gentle nutrition an hour or so before a morning workout. Extending the overnight fast is not the answer for a large pecentage of people. Blood sugar can be low for some in the morning too. Take care with this delayed breakfast idea. Be aware of how you feel if you try it. Please read my first sentence again. Namaste,Tracy (personal trainer and nutritionalist)
Thank you … I will work accordingly…
That is what I normally do.
At school i eat my “breakfast” which is at around 10 and i eat lunch when i get back at around 3. I eat supper (dinner) at around 8.
Since i sleep till late in the morning on holidays I also eat breakfast late.. and so on.
But maybe the reason why I’m not losing weight is that I may not be eating the right foods.
But I suppose I’m already used to it.
It doesnt work for everyone just as the eating 3 meals a day or not skipping breakfast works for everyone..this just happened to work for me, yes that really was me before…eww. Anyway…I had tried everything possible including the 3 meals a day believing if I didnt my metabolism would shut down but all it did was pack on weight. You know your body and how it responds to the amount of food you eat. I knew I couldnt do 3 meals a day, I never could or I would be as round as I was tall. The other really helpful thing Joey pointed out was writing down everything you eat, if you do this for a day or two you would be surprised how many calories you are taking in when you think you havent really eaten anything.
Hi Joey,ur 24th june article, i’m from nigeria.i’m a student in college who have lecture to attend everyday by 8;00am n most time close by twelve nooo,n i wake by 6am do my execise by 6;05 to 6;30am.138pounds. i’m i too to shift my breakfast forward.
Thank you for this article. I have also found that if i start my day by eating a early breakfast i tend to eat more throughout the day. I feel hungrier all day long. when i wait to eat breakfast later in the morning i do eat less. thank you cuz i thought i was going crazy.
Hi Joey, I think that you comment could work for alot of people, but I’m afraid to try it although it makes perfect sence to me.. I think my problem is…I get up at 4:30 am, eat breakfast around 5:30. work for 7am, my first break around 9am, lunch at 11:30 or 12:00 depends on the day, off at 3:30 then don’t have dinner till 5:45. I find that when I get home at 4:20, I could eat everything I get my hands on. If I would eat my breakfast later I woudl start shaking. so I don`t know what would work for me.
Hey just like to say that this works in reverse, too. I’m always hungry during the day but when dinner comes around I don’t feel like eating. So I eat most of my calories during the day when I actually need them and then eat like a cup of veggies for dinner. It’s really great because it feels like I eat a lot, but I acually end up eating the same amount or even less. It’s great, I recommend it.
I’ve been doing this for most of my life because if I eat breakfast, I feel sluggish for the first half of the day. Breakfast for me has always been a peach and some oats or something similar – healthy and small – but I still feel sluggish. If I wait until around 11 am and eat something with protein and a fruit I don’t feel like sleeping afterwards. My favorite new snacky thing to eat is a slice of organic turkey heated on the stove with no oil and folded in half on two slices of cucumber. The texture is really great and doesn’t have the added calories of bread!
Hi Joey,
Thanks for replying. I don’t really have a
weight problem. I weigh 48kgs. My problem is firming my buttocks as well as increasing the size of it. You gave me exercises to firm them. I’m doing the step ups for a few months now since a received your first sets of exercises. Step ups doesn’t make my knees sore. Doing squats make my knees sore.I noticed a very small improvement. I do the step ups 3x a day . I’m trying now the exercises you gave me a week ago and see how I go. I also want to develop the muscles in my inner side calves as I don’t seem to have it. Doing the step ups, would that develop my muscles as well inner side of my calves? Thanks for your reply.
Ann
Dear Joey,
Thank you for your instructions.
Yes, I am following your instructions , to expand my LBHT which you have provided in your web site. I can see the improvement day by day. Actually Its wonderfull.
Thank you so much.
Sandamali
Hey Joey,
Great article and good to be one of the few males responding on your site… i am a personal trainer from Australia and generally give my clients the 5 meals per day advice, ie. 3 “standard” meals plus mid-morning, mid-arvo snacks and also for those that dislike counting calories (most people!) i try to get them to reduce each meal by say 25% less, which is a form of portion control. Everyone is so different, different jobs, time availability, body type, likes/dislikes, etc. etc. etc… I am big fan of Tom Venuto’s http://www.BurnYourBodyFat.com material and just wondering how this goes “compared” to BFFM as the thinking seems very different at first?
Keep up the good work!
Cheers, Clayton.
i m plum not over weight…i do follow wat u said in this article,but i seem 2 be finding no difference.I would like to know wat kind off lower body exercises i can do to reduce my thighs n hips…please help..!!
Hi Joey,
I’ve found this article very interesting! But I could practice the calories shifting method only if I wake up late! because once I wake up I need my breakfast in the next 30min! So I’m usually up around 7 so I have my breakfast around that time. Then I do my workout for 30 min around 8.30 & after that I have a post workout meal (smoothie with berries & whey protein powder). I’ve read in many articles that eating every 3-4hours keeps your metabolism high so with this calories shifting method you basically only eat 3 meals a day. So doesn’t this method slows down your metabolism?? I wonder?
Hi Joey, thanks for everything till date. I am reading all your articles and trying it too but the shifting of calorie is very interesting one. i will surely give a try.
This is to Rania-
The reason I think you might be craving sweets after your workout is because you work into your sugar stores for your fuel source.
Check this guy’s site out. http://www.gettingfitover40.com
These are tips and there are 10. You get one each day. The last one goes into this exact challenge. Definitely check it out. I think it will answer your question perfectly.
Hi Joey,
Finding your advice very useful so far. I happen to agree with the “every method doesnt work for every BODY” theory,but the calorie shifting is a definite plus for me…I’ve always been told that breakfast is the most important meal of the day and most necessary if you are trying to lose weight, but i’m not a morning person so i always found it very hard to follow that rule because i’m never hungry that early in the morning and so use to force myself to eat something…
i’ve done diet after diet even those stupid weight loss pills (THEY DONT WORK PEOPLE), so i decided to forget about that and eat when i was hungry which is usually at around 10am and which moves lunch to 2 and dinner to like 6or 7 depending on what time i get home and my post workout snack of a banana or a whey protein shake(i go to the gym at 8pm and to my delight i put on a pant suit that used to fit quite tight and this morning i have all this room in the legs and the hip area and the jacket was very roomy in the in the midsection and arms.
I am absolutely ecstatic and this has motivated me to just keep pushing it. losing weight and getting/staying fit is not about the latest diet (THERE ARE THOUSANDS) its about knowing your body and what works for you eating right and getting lots of excercise.
Goodluck everybody and thanks for the advice Joey!!!
Hi Joey, I’ve never posted on your site before, I read all your e-mails though, but I had to comment on this article. I have been practicing this type of “eating” for years, I only wish I had shared this with someone sooner! I am NOT a traditional breakfast person I eat later after my workout, mainly because I’m not hungry that early in the morning but come 12, 1 even 2, I finally have my “breakfast”….here lately it has been soup. I have found that it curbs my appetite till dinner. If I am hungry when I get home I have some fruit, cheese and crackers, that holds me and lessens my appetite for dinner. I am 50 yrs. old and have weighed the same since high school! This might not work for everyone, but it has worked for me! Glad you shared this, hopefully this will help others as well!
Lena
wow! i never thought of this..i have been trying to reduce half a kg. its like a mission. i am doing regular walks, jogs and stretching exercise, but hungry all the time and i eat…i wake at 6.00 am and by 6.30 having my breakfast, 10.00 coffee and high caloried snack, lunch at 1, tea and snack at 6.00 and dinner snack at 8.00, phew, i feel like an animal, plus snacking in between.
i will try to shift my breakfast..hope i will be able to hold as i am not used to eat breakfast late after waking up, but i can always try.
thank you so much for this idea. this seems like an answer to my prayers…i am 49 years old…
Naina
Wow Joey what success! I glad people are happy. I, for 1 am not entirely happy because it is winter this side and,you know winter does in terms of weight gain,the scale is becoming my enemy.
PLEASE JOEY HELP ME! I need serios motivation and I want to buy ur books and exercise programs but I don’t know how. please help
I Joey it is my frist time writing to your email I like the article, I will give it a try to see have it will work for me. thank you.
Lucine
hi joey, i could find people saying that they could feel better and good after started doing the lhtb makeover which u sent me.thanks to that.can u send me the exercises for breast reduction, arm reduction,tummy reduction plz.
I like what you said about in the article and it makes sense, but….what if you are on the opposite end of the spectrum and you are running 5 to 7miles at 4am and in bed by 8pm every night?? Isn’t that just a different shift? My first meal is at 6:30am and my last is at 2pm. I like the idea of the “shift” but I think it is all relative to the lifestyle and times you are active.
I can easily try it out- As i work at night and get up at around 11- 12 o clock- So its pretty simple for me…….
I’m off to Australia for a month or so so will try this later breakfast/meals thingy and hope to see some improvement.
I will be walking lots as well-here’s hoping thanks.
joey you are such a blessing, i found your site by accident and i’ve never looked back. my issues are all over my body and i’ve been contemplating a tummy tuck among other things. my middle is very flabby and it drives me nuts. can you help joey?